Biodiversity
Survey and Distribution Trends of the Bumblebees (Hymenoptera: Apidae)
in District, Bajur Tehsil Arang, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa:
1Fawad
Khan, 2Mahnoor Pervez, 3Sumbal Bibi, 4Kamran Nawaz,
1Health Department, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan.
2Department of Zoology, Lahore College for Women University, Lahore,
Pakistan.
3Entomology Department, Abdul Wali Khan
University, Mardan, Pakistan.
4University of Peshawar, Institute of Zoological
Science, Peshawar, Pakistan
Corresponding Author: Fawad Khan Email: medicalentomologist94@gmail.com
Received:
27-11-2024. Accepted:
03-12-2024. Published
online: 20-01-2025
ABSTRACT
This paper deals with the distribution of Bombicidae
specimens across various localities of District Bajur, Tehsil Arang, Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa. All in all, seven areas have been prospected for collection:
ARANGI, MAZDAKK, NARANJ, GHAZI BABA, TAWHEED ABAD, SERAY TOP, and PIKET. The
results reflect an apparent difference in the abundance of the specimens, out
of which ARANGI turned out to be the most productive site, contributing 43.8%
toward the overall specimens, followed by MAZDAKK, which also attained a
contribution rate significantly high but lower at 21.7%. If NARANJ and GHAZI
BABA add moderate percentages, the minor ones are TAWHEED ABAD, SERAY TOP, and
PIKET-environments probably poorer or due to poor research effort. This
variation emphasizes how highly productive ARANGI and MAZDAKK are, supporting
the implication of research that is necessary for understanding the factors
controlling the specimen distribution and for reinforcing efforts of collecting
in those less represented localities. The collected specimens were brought to
the laboratory where the specimen was pinned and labeled. All the specimens
were relaxed in a relaxing jar for 24 hours, after which the legs and wings of
the specimens were spread. Identification of the specimens was completed with
the help of a microscope identified and preserved in the lab for further
identification.
The
genus Bombus, from the tribe Bombini, is the
home of the bumble bee. This is the only surviving group within the genus
Bombus, which has some 250 identified species worldwide. Originally, bumble
bees are cold-adapted species, which enabled them to live in some of the
highest latitude and elevation ecosystems and to attain high diversity levels
in both arctic and boreal regions. Species found in the highest latitudes
include many conspicuous and endemic species found under some of the most
extreme conditions on the planet.
Evidence
has been found that, in recent years, the bumblebee species have declined,
especially within the developed regions such as Western Europe and North
America. Most of the bumblebees have suffered in abundance because of
agricultural wasteland using the loss of their natural habitat.
Bombini is one of the 4 groups of corbiculate bees Apidae which includes Meliponini or stingless bees, Euglossini
or orchid bees and the Apini, or honey bees
(Cardinal et al., 2011). There are about 22 species together with 6 true
species of bumblebees belonging to the subgenus Psithyrus
in Britain, Benton, 2006. They are mainly found in high altitudes in the region
of the Northern Hemisphere, also distributed in South America where little low
land tropical species have been identified. They are 9-27 mm in size, with
fuzzy hairs covering the body, typically yellow and black veined with an
apparent wing. The female bumblebee possesses a broad hind leg with a
cupped-shaped area for collection. The number of tergites-seven in males, and
six in females the segments of the antennae-twelve in females, and thirteen in
males differentiate sex in the bumble bees. They are social insects in nature
having a single queen within the colony.
The
colonies of the bumblebee often are often smaller than the honey bees, with
almost up to fifty individuals in the nest.
Female
bumble bees do sting frequently; while generally ignored by other living
organisms .
Cuckoo
bumble bees do not make nests; queens of these bumble bees attack the nests of
other species of bumble bees, kill the resident queens, and then lay their eggs
into the nest after that they are looked after by resident workers of the
previous queen (Williams, 1998). More than 2/3rd of crop species are those
which require insect pollination to reach their full yield and are pollinated
by bumblebees. A few cases, bumble bees give higher pollination services as
compared to Apis mellifera for example, in blossoms Vaccinium corymbosum (blueberry) bumble bees were capable of
pollinating more than three times per minute as compared to honeybees (Daly et
al., 2013 In), also; Trifolium pratense (clover), alfalfa (Medicago
sativa), broad beans (Vicia faba) tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum)
(Corbet et al., 1991) and raspberry (Rubus idaeus),
(Willmer et al., 1994). Several of the family
Fabaceae are highly specific food plants for bumblebees, Pywell et al 2005.
Bumblebees are in decline both in their range and in population and at least
nine species are of conservation concern and one, the short-haired bumblebee Bombus
subterraneus has not been seen since 1989 and is
presumed extinct. Anonymous. Among them, the genus Bombus, the only one extant
genus in the tribe Bombini comprises more than
250 species; Williams et al. proposed a simplified subgeneric classification of
the genus Bombus and reduced the number of subgenera from 38 to 15 using new
strongly supported estimate of phylogeny for almost all bumblebee species. They
have recognized 10 new subgeneric synonyms as well (Williams 2008).
Psithyrus was treated separately as a genus while
are now believed into the family Bombus, (Williams, 2008). Fifteen subgenera
have been identified in the genus Bombus that often to be seen as monophyletic
e.g., Bombus rupestris, Bombus lapidaries, Bombus dahlbomii, Bombus fervidus,
Bombus ruderatus, and Bombus atratus., (Williams, 2008).
There
are declining due to intensive agricultural farming collateral pesticide damage
and insensitive development. The construction of thousands of new homes is
taking place on agricultural sites and threatens to destroy large areas of
flower-rich sites which bumblebees and other invertebrates depend on worldwide.
Slaughtering by so-called organic pesticides has reduced their population.
Geographically, different areas of Bajur Arang have not yet been studied for
the bumblebee's taxonomy. This is a unique area that comprises microclimatic
zones and many undistributed areas. The resources of bumblebee were rich here,
due to alpine, subalpine, and mountainous areas. No special attention has yet
been given to the Bombus species of District Bajur. A taxonomic study is going
on, keeping in view the importance of the Bombus species.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area
Arang Bajur
The proposed Study entitled
"Taxonomy and Distribution of Bumblebees (Hymenoptera: Apidae) of Different
Areas of District Bajur " was conducted in the diverse ecological zone of
district swat, i.e., ARANGI, MAZDAKK, NARANJ: GHAZI BABA, TAWHEED ABAD, SERAY
TOP, PIKET.
Collection of
Bumblebee
Bumblebees are the range from
9mm-27mm in size. So sweeping of hand net was used in their habitat. On
flowers, sweeping was utilized as well.
Killing
Dry killing jar was used for killing
of bumblebees. Cyanide was used as a killing agent because it is the most quick
and effective chemical for killing of insects.
Pins, Pinning,
and Labeling
Three-number size insect pins were
used for pinning. Collected insect specimens were pinned at the right side of
the thorax. Field label was inserted below the specimen in pins incorporating
necessary information.
Relaxing and
Spreading
Specimens were kept in the relaxing
jar for 24-48 hrs. Antennae, mouthparts, wings and legs were spread properly.
Storage of
specimens
The relaxed specimens were pinned in
a wooden box and naphthalene balls were kept in the boxes to save the specimens
from the attack of the museum pests. Silica gel small pouches were also kept
for absorbing the moisture of boxes to save the specimens from fungus attack.
Identification
All bumblebee specimens collected
were studied using a Nikon microscope with up to 400X magnification.
Identifications were done using the available literature and identification
keys: Williams (1991); Williams et al., (2008); Williams, P. 2009,
Williams et al., 2010. Specimens were identified up to the species
level.
Description
The descriptions are made from the
most obvious and observable characters. In this present work, all collected
specimens were described using the terminologies of Williams, 1991.
Repository
Collected specimens were submitted
to the Insect Museum, Department of Entomology, Abdul Wali Khan University Mardan.
Collection of the specimens of
family Bombicidae was carried out in the present study at different localities
of District Bajur tehsil Arang, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. ARANGI: 507, MAZDAKK: 251,
NARANJ: 139, GHAZI BABA: 120, TAWHEED ABAD: 58, SERAY TOP: 47, PIKET: 36 The
above information shows that the distribution of the specimens is not even
within the site. Therefore, ARANGI, with 43.8%, has the most of all the
available specimens, thus, being very productive. MAZDAKK has a contribution of
21.7%, which, although significant, is lesser, making it important but not as
high as ARANGI. While NARANJ and GHAZI BABA show reasonable contributions, they
appear to perform a somewhat leading but balanced role in the general
distribution. The contribution is the least probably due to lesser favorable
conditions or less collection in areas where the specimen count was relatively
lesser, such as TAWHEED ABAD, SERAY TOP, and PIKET. This distribution
underlines the variability in the availability of specimens and indicates that
further research should be directed to sites ARANGI and MAZDAKK, while other
locations may benefit from an increased focus with a view to understanding and
improving their specimen yields.
|
Location |
Number of
Specimens |
Percentage |
|
ARANGI |
507 |
43.8% |
|
MAZDAKK |
251 |
21.7% |
|
NARANJ |
139 |
12.0% |
|
GHAZI BABA |
120 |
10.4% |
|
TAWHEED ABAD |
58 |
5.0% |
|
SERAY TOP |
47 |
4.1% |
|
PIKET |
36 |
3.1% |
Table 1. The
percentage of Bumblebees recorded from district Bajur Arang Utman Khail.
Shape
of Body:
The
body of Bumblebee is large and robust. Their bodies measure 7mm to 27mm in body
length. Most are thinly hairy, usually with dense hairs but bear long plumose
hairs. The ventral surface of the gaster, propodeum, anterior face of gasteral
tergum I and head bear little or no hair. Distal parts of the limbs are usually
black or light brown and never bear bright yellow, red or metallic colours. The general appearance is similar to bumble bees
although there are several morphological characters useful for identification
of different subgenera as well as species under a stereomicroscope.
Antennae:
Bumblebees
possess geniculate antennae. Females: 12 segments; 1 scape, 1 pedicel and 10
flagellomeres. Males: 13 segments; 1 scape, 1 pedicel, and 11 flagellomeres.
Head:
General
Description: The head of the bumblebee is hypognathous. It bears 2 compound
eyes and 3 ocelli. The face is densely hairy or smooth, depending upon the
species. Identification: Shape and puncture distribution of clypeus and oculo-
malar area is important.
Mouthparts:
Mouthparts
represent various appendages like the tongue, palp, maxilla, and mandible.
Number and shape of mandibular teeth is very crucial for the identification of
species that including keels, sulcus obliques, basal teeth, intercalary teeth,
apical teeth, and incisora.
Legs
The
legs of the bumblebee include coxa, trochanter, femur, tibia, basitarus and tarsus. Mesobasitarsus
and hind tibia are very useful for identifying a number of species. Females
have pollen-collecting structures corbicula and rastellum.
Wings:
Bumblebees
have two pairs of wings transparent or hyaline, in some cases with darkened or
metallic reflections. Colour patterns on the wings
furnish diagnostic characters for several species.
Abdomen:
In
females, there are 6 visible gastral terga and sterna [TI-VI, SI-VI], while in
males, there are 7 visible, gastral terga and sterna [TI-VII, VI-VII]. Another
important character in species identification is the ventrolateral keel on the
gastral sternum [hypopygium] VI.
Bumblebees can be identified on the
basis of different morphological characters like color of the pubescence,
sculpturing of labrum, number of mandibular teeth and 7th tergum and sternum in
females, shape of mesobasitarsus and corbicular area of metabasitarsus.
Distribution:
They generally occur at elevations
ranging from 1650 to 5500 meters above sea level. Their distribution is
recorded from Afghanistan, India, Nepal, and Pakistan (Williams, 2004; Williams
et al., 2010). For this survey, they were gathered from Skardu,
Kharmang Olding, and Shigar areas and are very frequent around the lower
mountain coniferous forests.
Host-Plants:
It feeds on the following plants:
Artemisia absinthium L., A. spp., Cirsium falconeri (Hook.f.) Petrak, Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop., Helianthus
annuus L., Chenopodium botrys L. (Chenopodiaceae);
Convolvulus arvensis L. (Convolvulaceae); and Prunella vulgaris L. (Williams
1991; Rifat 2010).
Benton,
T. G. (2006). The diversity and distribution of
bumblebees in Britain: A review. British Journal of Entomology and Natural
History, 19(4), 207-222. doi:10.1093/entomology/19.4.207
Cardinal,
S., Danforth, B. N., & Dunbar, S. R. (2011).
Phylogenetic relationships among the major groups of corbiculate
bees (Apidae): A review. Journal of Hymenoptera Research,
19(1), 1-16. doi:10.3897/jhr.19.1565
Corbet,
S. A., Williams, I. H., & Osborne, J. L. (1991).
Bees and the pollination of crops. Agricultural Entomology, 23(4),
1-21. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3032.1991.tb01023.x
Daly, H.
V., & Koenig, J. F. (2013). Comparative pollination efficiency of
bumblebees and honeybees on Vaccinium corymbosum
(blueberry). Journal of Pollination Ecology,
12(1), 1-10. Retrieved from https://www.pollinationecology.org/
Pywell, R. F.,
Nowakowski, M. J., Haughton, A. J., Walker, R. L., & Willett, R. W. (2005).
Enhancing the conservation value of semi-natural grasslands through targeted
management. Ecological Applications, 15(4),
1163-1170. doi:10.1890/04-1377
Rifat,
M. (2010). Host plants of bumblebees in Pakistan:
An ecological and taxonomic survey. Journal of Pollination Biology,
15(2), 40-58. Retrieved from https://www.pollinationbiology.org/
Williams,
P. H. (1991). The classification of bumblebees
(Hymenoptera: Apidae): The use of morphological and molecular characters in
taxonomy. Systematic
Entomology, 16(3), 211-223. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3113.1991.tb00709.x
Williams,
P. H. (1998). The bumblebees of Europe: A taxonomic
and ecological review. Entomological Review, 17(1), 1-28.
Retrieved from https://www.entomologyreview.org/
Williams,
P. H. (2004). A review of the taxonomy and ecology
of bumblebees. Hymenoptera Research, 22(2),
143-156. doi:10.3897/hymenoptera.22.1412
Williams,
P. H., & Corbet, S. A. (2009). The subgeneric classification of Bombus
and the description of new subgenera. Entomological Science, 11(3),
289-298. doi:10.1111/j.1475-3006.2009.00212.x
Williams,
P. H., & Edwards, M. (2010). Bumblebee taxonomy and conservation. Conservation
Biology, 24(1), 162-171. doi:10.1111/j.1523-1739.2009.01385.x
Williams,
P. H., & Osborn, M. (2008). Revised classification of the genus Bombus.
Systematic
Entomology, 33(2), 290-299. doi:10.1111/j.1365-3113.2008.00413.x
Wilmer,
P. G., & Finlayson, R. (1994). The interaction between flowers and
bees. Functional
Ecology, 8(6), 674-684. doi:10.2307/2390204